Property purchase tax boost necessary to reduce demand



The July 25 introduction of a 15 per cent property purchase tax on foreign buyers by the provincial government surprised many observers, and shocked the real estate industry.
In particular, foreign buyers with transactions in progress were caught in a dilemma. If they were able to move the completion date up, they could avoid the tax. Some did so. Others walked away from signed contracts, forfeiting deposits which in some cases were substantially lower than the tax bill would have been.
Philip Dumoulin of Sotheby’s International Realty in South Surrey said one realtor lost three buyers and a fourth asked for a referral to Toronto, planning to buy there instead of in the Greater Vancouver area.
Foreign buyers have had less direct impact in Surrey than in some other parts of Greater Vancouver, such as the City of Vancouver, Burnaby, Richmond and areas of the North Shore. However, there have been a significant number of such buyers in South Surrey and White Rock, and it is likely some also bought homes in Fraser Heights, which already has a sizable population of Asian background.
As happened in the late 1980s and early 1990s, it isn’t just foreign buyers who influence property prices in Surrey. At that time, many buyers from Hong Kong bought homes in Vancouver to hedge their bets, not knowing what the pending jurisdictional takeover of Hong Kong by the Chinese government would mean.
Many people who sold properties to Hong Kong buyers at that time bought homes and moved outside Vancouver. A significant number came to Surrey, Delta and White Rock, and that boosted prices here. This came after a prolonged slump in the real estate market, caused by 20 per cent interest rates in the early 1980s and a lengthy economic downturn.
A similar thing has happened in this boom. In recent months, real estate prices in virtually all Surrey neighbourhoods have increased sharply. Detached homes in particular have been in demand.
While prices in many parts of Surrey are substantially below prices in most areas of the Burrard Peninsula, they are still much higher than they have ever been. Even with low interest rates, this makes owning a home a challenge. Making payments can become a struggle, and if interest rates ever rise, there is a high risk of many homeowners defaulting.
The 15 per cent property purchase tax is designed to crimp demand, not just from foreign buyers, but from people who are relocating to other areas of the Lower Mainland. A chilling of demand is long overdue. Realtors have been saying for the past year that a shortage of supply was exacerbating demand, and no matter how many new homes came onto the market, it didn’t seem to affect the demand.
What is equally important in any discussion of housing supply and demand is recognition that the rental supply needs to be increased. More and more people are coping with rent increases that they cannot handle. With real estate prices so high, more people have no choice but to remain renters. This puts upward pressure on rents.
The provincial government has put $75 million into a fund to build rental housing, and also promises that revenues from the new higher property purchase tax will go into this fund. This substantial commitment to creating new rental stock is very important.
Renters and housing advocates must insist that work begin right away on building new rental housing. Local governments need to identify sites where rental housing can be built quickly and fast track approvals.
Housing market challenges were left to their own devices for too long, and the situation got out of hand. That was a key factor leading to the drastic tax increase, which definitely sends a negative message to foreign investors. Measures to increase the supply of homes for purchase and rental are welcome. A decline in demand is also a good step in the right direction.

Comments

  1. Unknown23 September 2016 at 02:51

    Thanks for sharing such valuable information on property taxes. Last month my nephew bought his new home from Dove mountain real estate and he got quite impressed with their location as well as interiors. Glad he found his dream home.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Bad day at Black Press

Image
News today that Black Press has voluntarily entered creditor protection and could be sold to a three-way partnership is the latest in a long string of bad news stories for community newspapers. David Black, longtime owner and founder of Black Press, is out of the newspaper business after more than 50 years. It has been a sad day for me. I have spent the past 46 years involved with the community press, mostly as a reporter and editor. I was a Black Press editor for 16 years with The Langley Times, retiring from full-time work in 2015. I am particularly saddened when I think of the many great people I worked with at various newspapers, most of them now owned by Black Press. Some still work there, some have retired, some have left this world behind. Community newspapers have been struggling to find an arrangement that works for them, as businesses, and for their readers, for the better part of 20 years. This became a particular challenge when smart phones, notably the iPhone, made their a
Read more

Capital parcel tax biggest culprit in massive Surrey tax increase

Image
Property taxes in Surrey jumped by far more than the 2.9 per cent claimed by Mayor Doug McCallum. The biggest culprit is the capital parcel tax, which jumped by 200 per cent for every single property in the city. This is steep - and regressive. Many Surrey residents are upset about the boost in their property taxes. Some say they have gone up 15 to 20 per cent - a far cry from Mayor Doug McCallum’s claim that they were only boosted a modest 2.9 per cent. Property taxes are complex although Surrey, to its credit, breaks down the portion collected for its operations quite specifically. Not all municipalities do so. The Surrey property tax bill also includes a significant amount for schools, as well as small amounts for B.C. Assessment Authority, Metro Vancouver and TransLink. There is no doubt that McCallum’s claim was misleading, right from the moment council adopted its 2021 budget. A 200 per cent increase in the parcel tax, from $100 to $300, ensured that everyone’s taxes would rise f
Read more

Reconciliation starts at home

Image
Frank Bucholtz photo Joanne Charles, councillor with Semiahmoo First Nation, shared some powerful words about reconciliation with an attentive audience at the Semiahmoo Spirit Stage on Monday night, as part of a  community discussion on reconciliation, diversity and equality/ The event was one of a series of community discussions hosted by organizers of the Gordie Hogg Liberal campaign in the federal riding of South Surrey-White Rock. With her on stage is emcee Deb Saih. The discovery of unmarked grave sites at four former residential school properties has changed the tenor of discussion about Canada’s relationships with indigenous people. Local governments have an important role to play in the process of meaningful reconciliation - as do all of us as citizens. Delta council has gone a fair ways down that path, largely due to a treaty with the Tsawwassen First Nation,  and White Rock’s relationship with the Semiahmoo First Nation is improving considerably, after some rough patches a fe
Read more